- Startup Obituary
- Posts
- Startup Obituary : Clinkle
Startup Obituary : Clinkle
Clinkle: When Hype Outran Reality. The $30 Million App That Never Worked.
Ram Gangisetty
August 27, 2025
🚀 The “Next Zuckerberg” Raises a Record-Breaking Round
In 2013, 21-year-old Lucas Duplan convinced Silicon Valley’s biggest names to pour $30 million into his payments startup Clinkle — the largest seed round in history at the time. Backers included Andreessen Horowitz, Peter Thiel, Marc Benioff, Accel Partners’ Jim Breyer, Richard Branson, and Intel Capital.
Yet by 2016, Clinkle was dead. It had launched a confusing debit card app no one wanted, gone through multiple pivots, and alienated most of its employees. Duplan had become Silicon Valley’s favorite punchline — a poster child for what happens when vision, money, and youth collide without accountability.
"Our goal is to completely modernize how payments work,"
🎬 Act I: Stanford, Ultrasound, and a Star Is Born
It started in 2011 with a 19-year-old Stanford student named Lucas Duplan. Inspired during a study abroad trip to London—where foreign currency made it hard to buy lunch—Duplan dreamed up an app to make mobile payments effortless. His secret sauce? Ultrasound technology that would let phones communicate in stores with high-frequency sound.
The idea was stealthy, but the hype was deafening.
Duplan recruited a dozen classmates, locked themselves in a Palo Alto house, and began building. His connections (and charm) opened elite doors. Before long, he was pitching Silicon Valley royalty—including Peter Thiel, Marc Benioff, and Andreessen Horowitz.
💰 In June 2013, Clinkle announced a $25 million seed round—the largest in Silicon Valley history at the time. By the end of the year, it had raised over $30 million.
🚪 The Culture: Top-Down and Tense
Clinkle was notorious for secrecy. Most employees didn’t know what they were building. The press didn’t either.
🧑💼 In October 2013, Duplan brought on Barry McCarthy, former Netflix CFO, as COO. He left in less than five months. As McCarthy told Fortune:
“They’re not nearly as close to scaling the business as I thought they were when I came in the door.”
That same month, Clinkle hired Yahoo alum Chi-Chao Chang as VP of Engineering. According to Business Insider, he quit after just one day when he discovered the company planned more layoffs.
📉 In December 2013, Clinkle laid off 25% of its staff—just six months after raising the $25M round. Employees were reportedly notified via a Sunday email to show up early Monday, only to be told to turn in their laptops.
By early 2014, the team had burned through $10–15 million—and Clinkle still had no product.
💳 What Clinkle Actually Launched
After years of stealth, secrecy, and $30 million in cash, Clinkle finally launched in September 2014. The product? Not a wallet killer. Not a Venmo disruptor. Not even ultrasound.
It was… a prepaid debit card.
Branded as “Clinkle,” the card came with a rewards gimmick called Treats. Every 7th purchase earned a “Treat” that users had to send to a friend. The friend could then get a surprise refund of up to $25 on their next purchase. A sort of “social slot machine.”
💸 As TechCrunch explained:
“Users would earn a Treat for every seventh purchase with their Clinkle debit card, which earned the startup interchange fees that typically go to the card issuer.
But critics were unimpressed.
Even worse? There was a $20 fee to close your account, according to Business Insider.
🧨 The Implosion
In May 2015, things came crashing down.
📉 Seven senior employees resigned at once—including the VP of Engineering and the CFO—after Duplan reportedly fired them for asking questions about a possible acquisition offer.
With only ~12 employees left and no traction, Clinkle pivoted. It abandoned the debit card and began pitching “Treats” as an SDK for other apps. No one bit.
🔥 The Backlash and Burnout
Clinkle didn’t just fail. It became a punchline.
A leaked image of Duplan and Richard Branson burning fake $100 bills at a party (symbolizing the “death of cash”) went viral—for all the wrong reasons.
In 2016, Clinkle officially shut down.
Scorecard: Clinkle
Dimension | Score | Reasoning |
|---|---|---|
Product-Market Fit | 1/5 | The core product—an ultrasound-powered payment app—was never delivered. What did launch (a prepaid debit card with gimmicks) had no real market demand. |
USP | 2/5 | Treats was novel, but not valuable. The core tech pitch (ultrasound payments) was never realized in-market. No compelling differentiation from Venmo, Square, etc. |
Timing | 2/5 | Mobile payments were heating up (Apple Pay launched same year). But Clinkle was years late with a half-baked card gimmick—timing alone couldn’t save it. |
Founder Fit | 1/5 | Lucas Duplan was a 19-year-old with no experience and no leadership training, managing $30M. Toxic culture, mass resignations, and secrecy sealed the deal. |
Team (Execution) | 1/5 | High turnover, secrecy, zero transparency. No real product for years. Treats SDK went nowhere. COO and senior leaders fled. Burned $30M with no traction. |
🧠 Lessons for Founders & VCs
🧪 Product ≠ Demo: Clinkle never validated its core tech. A flashy pitch deck is not product-market fit.
🧍♂️ Founder Fit Matters: Duplan had zero leadership experience. His poor management style led to 93% turnover.
🧾 Structure Your Deals Right: The convertible note funding meant no board, no accountability, and no chance to course-correct.
🎯 Don’t Pivot Into the Void
Each new Clinkle pivot moved further from what users wanted. There was no anchor.
🌐 Fundraising ≠ Success: Clinkle joins other Startup Obituary subjects like Juicero, Color, and Beepi — all companies that raised tens of millions only to flame out spectacularly.
I hope this story highlights the perils in not validating the product and importance of managemnet skills for founders.
It took a lot of effort in writing this and thank you for your appreciation by sharing on your social channels.
Cheers,
Ram
👉 My simple ask: It took hours to put together this post for you. I hope you forward this email to at least one founder friend or share on your social channels 🙏.
Startup Obituary is for educational purpose only not a business advice.
How was this post?
😀 😎 😔
Reply